London Clubland: A Companion for the Curious by Seth Alexander Thévoz

 

'The British have always liked the certainty of club membership': The controversial UK clubs that kept women out

21 hours ago

https://www.bbc.com/culture/article/20250708-the-controversial-uk-clubs-that-kept-women-out

Clare McHugh

 

Three hundred years since they first appeared, the capital's traditional members-only gentlemen's clubs – still frequented by royalty and power brokers – have endured and evolved. As controversy continues around The Garrick permitting women members, a new book explores this peculiarly British phenomenon.

 

For more than three centuries, London has been the global centre of private members' clubs. In no other place have so many of these secretive sanctuaries come and gone, and today, with a total of 133 operating, the British capital still outstrips its closest rival, New York City, which hosts a mere 53 clubs. 

 

Many of the historic men-only London clubs have moved with the times, and now allow female members. And arguably the most famous in traditional clubland, the Garrick Club, founded in 1831, made the news last year when it finally decided to drop its men-only rule. Since then, however, only a handful of women has been elected as members there, and, last month, broadcast journalist Julie Etchingham withdrew her candidacy. Reportedly, some prospective female candidates are uncomfortable with the protracted vetting process and seeming hostility of numerous members to women joining. The Savile Club, meanwhile, voted earlier this year to keep women out. Hidebound attitudes remain, it seems.

 

Clubs speak to something deeply-rooted in human character the world over, and in the UK they have special resonance

 

Now a new book, London Clubland: A Companion for the Curious, by Dr Seth Alexander Thévoz, provides a club-by-club overview, along with a deep dive into their particularities – customs, rules, traditions and even a few recipes. Clubs have often needed to evolve in order to survive, Thévoz reveals, and those that endure tend to serve a distinct membership.

 

The author believes that while clubs speak to something deeply-rooted in human character the world over, in the UK they have special resonance. He tells the BBC: "The British have always liked the certainty of club membership, and have been hugely into associational culture, from young people joining the Scouts and Girl Guides, to older people volunteering for an amateur dramatics society."

 

How it began

 It all started with coffee. In the second half of the 17th Century, when coffee drinking was first introduced to England, coffee houses were a welcome alternative to taverns and became associated with good conversation. Samuel Pepys wrote in December 1660 of his evening at the "Coffee-house" in Cornhill: "I find much pleasure in it through the diversity of company – and discourse."

 

In 1693, an Italian migrant to London, Francesco Bianco (who anglicised his name to Francis White), opened an establishment that served both coffee and hot chocolate; he called it Mrs White's Chocolate House. Patrons flocked to St James's Street, not only for the hot beverages, but for the gambling room – the site of illegal, high-stakes card games – tucked away at the back of the premises. White's is still operating, and is London's oldest club. Only men are allowed to join. (King Charles counts among its 1500 members; he held his stag night at White's before his 1981 wedding to Princess Diana.)

 

Numerous other clubs opened in this manner throughout the Georgian era, Thévoz notes, because gambling dens labelled "private members' clubs" were more difficult for the authorities to raid. As the aristocratic membership increasingly demanded food and entertainment along with their gaming, hospitality professionals took over the management. Brooks's (founded 1764) is another Georgian club that has survived to this day, along with Boodle's (1762), originally called Almack's. Boodle's "is probably the best-preserved 18th-Century clubhouse", Thévoz tells the BBC – passers-by can recognise it by its iconic front-facing bow window.

 

Boom time

It was during the 19th Century that clubs in London boomed – approximately a dozen existed at the start of the century, and 400 by the end. Clubs in general became less louche, in step with a new, Victorian interest in propriety. Most significantly, they took on a central role in British politics, and scores of political clubs were founded in central London in these years, in a swathe of the city bound by Piccadilly to the north, Pall Mall to the south, St James's Street to the west, and Haymarket to the east. Several of the most renowned, party-affiliated clubs have endured to this day. The Carlton Club, the Conservative stronghold, founded in 1832, was from the start a hotbed of gossip and political intrigue. The Duke of Wellington, at one time a member, advised on his deathbed: "Never write a letter to your mistress and never join the Carlton Club."

 

The Reform Club was established in 1836 on Pall Mall to provide a hub for Whigs and Radicals, and later Liberals. It is also a setting in Around the World in Eighty Days, the 1872 novel by Jules Verne – the protagonist Phileas Fogg makes a £20,000 bet with six members that he can circumnavigate the globe and arrive back "in this very room of the Reform Club" in 80 days' time.

 

'The best club in London'

When in October 1834 a massive fire destroyed the old Houses of Parliament, many of the functions of government relocated to the clubs. The new Palace of Westminster was modelled after a private members' club, with tea rooms, smoking rooms and libraries, prompting Charles Dickens in 1864 to call the House of Commons "the best club in London".

 

The prince, a dedicated bon viveur, got fed up with the amount of gossip that was leaking out of White's about his amorous activities – and founded his own club

 

 One of the first clubs open to both men and women, The Albemarle Club, founded in 1874, was associated from the start with the burgeoning women's rights movement. It became notorious when member Oscar Wilde was confronted there by the Marquess of Queensbury, father of his lover Lord Alfred Douglas, in an incident that set off the ill-fated libel trial that would lead to Wilde's conviction and imprisonment.

 

Royalty has always favoured London clubs, but none more enthusiastically than Albert Edward, the Prince of Wales, later King Edward VII. The prince, a dedicated bon viveur, got fed up with the amount of gossip that was leaking out of White's about his amorous activities, Thévoz explains. The prince decided to found his own club, the Marlborough Club, named after his London residence, in 1869. He handpicked the first 400 members, and retained ultimate black-ball power, so he could veto the membership of anyone he didn't trust.

 

At the dawn of the 20th Century, London clubs were still going strong, and providing fodder for fiction writers. According to Thévoz, the Drones Club featured in PG Wodehouse's work most closely resembles Buck's Club in Mayfair, founded in 1919. The club was immediately popular for its US-style cocktail bar. The signature drink was, then and now, the Buck's Fizz – Champagne and orange juice with a mysterious twist.

 

In 2023, conservative establishment Pratt's surprised many by admitting women for the first time

 

Ian Fleming was a member of Boodle's, upon which he based Blade's club in his James Bond books. In Evelyn Waugh's novel Brideshead Revisited, protagonist Charles Ryder gathers with friends at Bratt's, most likely inspired by Pratt's, a small supper club in St James's founded in 1857, and owned since 1926 by the family of the Duke of Devonshire. In 2023, this most conservative of establishments surprised many by admitting women for the first time.

 

Clubs for women enjoyed a heyday in the last decade of the 19th Century and the first of the 20th, numbering 86 in all by Thevoz's count. Some were patronised by wealthy women in town for shopping and the theatre. Others were residential, offering affordable accommodation to single women beginning careers in the capital. Muriel Spark, in her 1963 novel The Girls of Slender Means, based the May of Teck Club, where her protagonists live, on The Service Women's Club.

 

Over the past 100 years, nine out of 10 of the venerable members' clubs closed. The long period of decline – beginning roughly in the early 1920s and accelerating after World War Two – bottomed out in the 1970s. A change in social mores, a dwindling number of ageing members, and steeper fees all played their part in this downturn.

 

Those clubs that continued to survive most often had a strong identity, and catered to a distinctive group, such as the military (the In and the Out Club), actors (the Garrick) or horse-racing enthusiasts (the Turf Club). Of the many historic private clubs for women in London, only one remains, University Women's Club in Mayfair. Other more recent iterations of women-only clubs have had mixed results.

 

A modern renaissance

Mark Birley began a successful run of "new" clubs in 1963 with the members-only nightclub Annabel's, located in a cavernous basement on Berkeley Square. He used his extensive contacts among the upper classes to attract members – it is said to be the only nightclub into which Queen Elizabeth II ever set foot.

 

But the real modern renaissance of London clubs began in 1985, with the antithesis of the old gentleman's club: a sparky, mixed-sex space, where admission was based not on social rank but on achievement. The name, the Groucho Club, is a hat-tip to Groucho Marx's famous remark that he would never want to be in a club that would have him as a member. Established in Soho, it quickly attracted a starry clientele – Stephen Fry wrote the club's original rule book, which insisted on traditional discretion.

 

My grandfather saw the clubs of London dominated by a clique of 'bores and oafs', the self-conscious, self-appointed retainers of high culture – Pierre Waugh

 

Also in 1985, writer Auberon Waugh along with Victoria Glendinning founded the Academy Club. "My grandfather's knee-jerk intolerance of any type of pomposity inspired the Academy," grandson Pierre Waugh tells the BBC. "At the time of its creation, he saw the clubs of London dominated by a clique of 'bores and oafs', the self-conscious, self-appointed retainers of high culture." Waugh's baby continues to attract a literary membership today. Thévoz reports: "The facilities are rather modest, though that is part of the charm."  

 

In the 19th Century, such was the popularity of the top clubs, including the Athenaeum and the Carlton, that prospective members could wait three decades to enter. Now at the Hurlingham in Fulham, the closest thing to a US-style country club in London, it can take a similar amount of time to be admitted, with priority given to the existing members' immediate family members.

 

Dominating members clubs in the 21st Century are the proprietary clubs (as opposed to committee-run clubs), most notably Soho House, a large international money-making operation with dozens of locations. In London, the group includes venues in Greek Street and Dean Street, where Harry and Meghan, Duke and Duchess of Sussex, reportedly went on their first date.

 

If the past is any guide, the London club, ever morphing, will continue to be a feature of life in the capital for the foreseeable future, an indication of its citizens' abiding interest in conversation, eating and drinking in environs that in some way they can call their own.

 

And clubs will no doubt remain a subject of fascination and gossip. The latest news on the Garrick is that those members of the club antagonistic to potential women members, including Etchingham, have formed a WhatsApp group. Naturally enough it has called itself "Status Quo".

 

London Clubland: A Companion for the Curious by Seth Alexander Thévoz is published by Little Brown

 

Clare McHugh is the author of the historical novel The Romanov Brides, published by Harper Collins.