‘She was
a monster’: the real Patricia Highsmith, by the people who knew her
A new
film starring Helen Mirren explores the Ripley writer’s later years, but was
she really so rude and eccentric? Editors and publishers who worked with her
look back
Sun 15
Nov 2026 13.00 CET
Publisher
and bookseller Otto Penzler has loved Patricia Highsmith’s work all his life,
but their first meeting was a washout. In 1984, she agreed to
give a reading at The Mysterious Bookshop, his store on West 56th Street in New
York. The American author of the Ripley novels, then 63, had lived in Europe
for 20 years – in England, then France, then Switzerland – and seldom made
public appearances, so he had high hopes.
“But no
one showed up. We had maybe four people,” Penzler says from his book-lined
office under the shop. Now 84, with a tidy white beard and a warm, amused
manner, he is just back from a crime fiction convention and still very much in
the game. Highsmith, he recalls, had little time for her readers. “She was
somewhat taciturn. People got their book signed and left within five minutes. I
had a two-hour event scheduled, so what does one do? With some authors, I can
say, ‘Let me buy you dinner.’ Well, not with Pat.” She stonewalled his small
talk about France with an “I can’t stand the bloody frogs”.
Highsmith,
who was born in Fort Worth, Texas, in 1921, had a hit with her 1950 debut,
Strangers on a Train, boosted by Alfred Hitchcock’s film. A perfect second
novel, lesbian road trip The Price of Salt (later republished as Carol), sold a
million copies under the pseudonym Claire Morgan, and The Talented Mr Ripley
(1955) was a critical success. But around the mid-1960s, Highsmith’s
American luck ran out: her agent wrote that her books were “too
subtle”, her characters too unlikable, to make it into paperback. By 1984 she
was without an American publisher.
“She
never found a home because she was so unpleasant,” Penzler says. “I don’t
think anybody said, ‘Oh look, we’re losing money but I love her so much, let’s
keep her.’” Not yet knowing this, he signed a six-book deal with Highsmith,
creating a new imprint in the process. “Pat didn’t want to be identified as a
mystery writer, so I started Penzler Books.” He knew Highsmith’s first
editor, Joan Kahn. “When I told her I’d bought Pat, she said: ‘God, what’s
wrong with you?’ Later we agreed she was a monster.”
When a
publicist brought roses, Pat threw hers on the floor without making eye
contact. You can’t imagine a person like this
Otto
Penzler, publisher
In Anton
Corbijn’s new film A Talent for Murder, adapted from Joanna Murray-Smith’s
2014 play, Switzerland, a dying Highsmith is played by Helen Mirren, who nails
her physicality with dark contact lenses, a wig and a way of seeming to
make her neck disappear. By 1995, when the film is set, Highsmith had
lived alone for years, ending her last relationship with the translator Monique
Buffet, then 27, when she was 66. Tortured by her sexuality, unrequited
love and a poisonous mother, happiness largely eluded her.
The
film’s premise is that a young American editor must persuade Highsmith to write
one last Ripley novel: if she signs, his job is guaranteed and her uncertain
legacy assured. It’s a fiction, of course, though lovingly built on real
details, from the water glasses filled with cigarettes to her tank of pet
snails and the Bond villain bunker she designed.
The image
of the misanthrope has helped keep Highsmith’s legacy alive, with Ripley
recently remade by Netflix, but has the knife-collecting sadist become a
caricature? Did she deserve greater recognition in America? She hated
publicity, which made life tricky for her champions. Penzler remembers that on
one book tour, “my wife and I took her to our most beloved Italian restaurant.
A young publicist, whose job it was to take Pat to all the interviews, came
with two long-stemmed roses. My wife said, ‘Oh, what a sweet thing!’ Pat threw
hers on the floor without making eye contact. You can’t imagine a person like
this.”
After
that, Penzler took on chaperoning duties. The interviews were brief and
sometimes never published. “The one time Pat said something positive was when I
asked if she’d like to stop for a drink. She said, ‘I would have a beer. I like
beer.’” Highsmith’s Swiss editor, Anna von Planta, recalled a similar first
encounter in 1984: “Pat greeted me coolly, disregarding my extended hand. She
then ordered a beer and fell silent.”
Helen
Mirren as Highsmith in A Talent for Murder. Photograph: Everett Collection
Inc/Alamy
By 1967,
Highsmith had begun a lifelong relationship with the Swiss publisher Diogenes,
who took control of her literary estate when she died – as well as 56 volumes
of unpublished diaries, letters and stories, neatly filed at the back of her
linen cupboard. Those diaries laid bare Highsmith’s antisemitism and racism. In
her introduction to a published edition of them, in 2021, Von Planta writes
that Highsmith’s views have been represented faithfully, even where offensive,
but that “in a handful of more extreme instances [we did] feel it our editorial
duty to deny Pat a stage for them, in the same way we did while she was still
alive”. Did Penzler ever feel she crossed a line? “She hated so much, including
women. If there was antisemitism in her stories, I probably missed it because
it was mild compared to the other things.”
Even
those who were repelled by Highsmith’s prejudices shared an appreciation of her
work – its strangeness, precision, gift for character and its unfashionable
darkness. The horror of the Tom Ripley novels lies not so much in their
violence (though there is plenty of that), as in his increasing enjoyment of
it. Does he mean to murder an art collector with a bottle of Margaux
in Ripley Under Ground? “Tom simply could not answer that. And did it matter,
much?”, she writes. That bleakness sold better in Europe: even a weak late
novel, Found in the Street, sold 40,000 copies in Germany compared with 4,000
in America.
Gary
Fisketjon was Highsmith’s next and final American editor, at Atlantic and then
Knopf. He died suddenly of a stroke on 7 November, aged 72, but when I spoke to
him a week earlier he had nothing but good memories of her. She was no pussycat
but nor were his other authors — among them Jay McInerney, Donna Tartt and Cormac McCarthy.
He still had regrets over a lunch that never quite came together with
Highsmith, Bret Easton Ellis and Michel Houellebecq, which would have been
quite the nihilist triumvirate: you can draw a direct line from Tom Ripley to
Patrick Bateman.
“We never
had a cross word,” Fisketjon said on the phone from Oregon. “I took Pat for
dinner at the Odeon, which was very popular. Kind of a chic, downtown,
artistic crowd and whatnot, and she was just captivated. She was studying
everybody in the room.” In a 1984 diary entry, Highsmith wrote that “it will be
interesting to see what good writers come from the cocaine takers”, and in the
mid-80s literary scene she had her answer.
Highsmith
in June 1985. Photograph: Dino Fracchia/Alamy
At the
Frankfurt book fair, she and Fisketjon talked about their cats. “She was a
superstar in Germany, and she was careful to instruct me on the best way to
drink their beer, with the foam on top.” Fisketjon published Found in the
Street (1987) and the final Ripley novel, Ripley Under Water (1991), giving
notes in the same way he would for anyone else. “The ideal was, and this
happened a few times with Pat – she’d say, ‘I see what you’re getting at, but
here’s a better way of improving it.’” When Hollywood scouts took him for
lunch, he told them to look at Highsmith’s backlist. “But the notion of getting
in touch with a Swiss publisher to make a deal was unusual. She was an outlier,
living abroad.”
Fisketjon
had passed on her final novel, Small g: A Summer Idyll, feeling he “couldn’t
publish it as fervently as Pat deserved. She took it better than I
feared.” They stayed friends, trading letters and cat news. He had seen A
Talent for Murder a couple of days earlier, and liked it, while finding the
plot implausible. “Dame Mirren’s expressions reminded me vividly of Pat, even
if her personality was a lot darker than I ever saw.”
Liz
Calder looked after Highsmith at Bloomsbury in the late 1980s until the
author’s death, and gets a mention in her diaries: a dinner in Hampstead in
1992, with her “parrot called Jon-Jon – maybe 38, light green”. “Actually it
was Juju,” Calder says, “but they communicated quite well. I think she was
more interested in the parrot than any of us.”
Now 88,
she remembers Highsmith as “very, very unusual. She would comment a lot on
things around her – ‘look, something’s happening over there’ – or on what
I was wearing. She was almost unsocialised.” At the same time, she had close
friends in London, France and Switzerland. “People who were nothing to do with
her work. She loosened up with me over time but I never met them.”
Highsmith
died of lung cancer and anaemia on 4 February 1995, aged 74. The American
papers ran obituaries but there was no bump in sales. When editor Robert
Weil approached Diogenes about publishing a couple of her books at WW Norton in
1998, they insisted he acquire all 14 that were then out of print in America,
including Strangers on a Train. “I was new at Norton. They said, ‘This is
folly, the sales don’t bear up.’ But I was persistent.” He agreed to Diogenes’s
terms, eventually taking on her last unpublished novel, Small g, as well as the
Ripleys, Carol and dozens of unpublished stories.
Now an
executive editor at the Norton imprint Liveright, Weil speaks from a New York
office lined with Highsmith box sets. Actor Alden Ehrenreich spent time here
while researching A Talent for Murder (“he was a wonderful fly on the wall”)
and Weil thinks there is still more to be done with Highsmith. Small g was “not
her best work”, but a new collection of short stories got “thundering reviews”
in 2001. By then, Anthony Minghella’s 1999 film adaptation of The Talented Mr
Ripley had renewed interest in her writing.
Highsmith
was rude and bigoted. But her work would have been impossible without empathy
“What she
could do in 12 pages was amazing,” says Weil. “Highsmith can write these
stories where you feel stabbed at the end – she knows how to finish something.”
He reckons there are at least five potential screenplays in a 2002 collection,
Nothing That Meets the Eye, which must include A Girl Like Phyl, about a
man who meets his lost love’s daughter on a plane (“The girl looked at
him, happened to lift her eyes straight toward him, and Jeff felt as if he had
been shot”) and the title story, about a woman who bewitches every man in
a ski resort before jumping from a mountain. Highsmith follows the body all the
way down, to the “dark and final click” of death.
“There
are a few happy stories,” Weil adds. “There’s an evocation of New York in the
late 40s which is so precise and loving. But she had a gimlet eye for
hypocrisy.” Exile gave her clarity. “She learned to skin and savage
America. She never left it psychologically.” In her understanding of
greed, she is like Edith Wharton, Weil says. “But in terms of psychological
manipulation, there are very few like Highsmith. She was so far from the
mainstream, and she should have been a debutante from Dallas.”
Highsmith
was rude and sometimes bigoted. She also had a capacity for friendship, and for
work that would have been impossible without empathy. Both things can be true,
as her favourite creation Ripley attests – beneath the good man lies an evil
one; beneath her cruel exterior lay someone capable of kindness.
In March
1995 Liz Calder caught a train to Highsmith’s memorial service at the Chiesa di
Tegna in Switzerland, accompanied by her UK agent Tanja Howarth. They had both
found Highsmith difficult. “But we wanted to go. And it was very strange –
it was well attended but not by many publishing people. Tanja and I didn’t
know anybody.” The Highsmith they knew was not the one her friends mourned. She
was a mystery to the last.
A Talent
for Murder is released in cinemas on 20 November.

.jpeg)



No comments:
Post a Comment